Why Pascha Is When It IsThe date of Easter uses the spring equinox, the full moon, and the Synod of Whitby.
Pascha is celebrated on a different date every year. And most years, Easter and Pascha are celebrated on different days, even though they both celebrate the Feast of the Resurrection of Christ. Often, people want to know why Pascha is when it is, and why Pascha and Easter are on different days.
As with many of life’s more interesting questions, the answer is that it’s complicated.
The Jewish calendar and the spring equinox
In the first centuries of the Church, some Christians celebrated the Resurrection of Christ on the 14th day of the Jewish month of Nisan. Others celebrated it on the Sunday following that date. Regardless of which date they chose, they usually settled on the date by asking their Jewish neighbors when the 14th of Nisan would be. But in the fourth century, the Jews changed the way they calculated the date of Passover. The change made it possible for the 14th of Nisan to come before the spring equinox. That was a bit of a problem. Christians knew that the Resurrection of Christ had happened after the equinox. Many believed that, to properly honor the date, Pascha should be celebrated after the equinox as well. More important, though, the changes just made the old problem worse. Some Christians celebrated their most important feast on one day, and some on another. Everyone wanted to celebrate together.
The Council of Nicea and the Synod of Whitby
By the year 325, the Church had any number of problems to solve. So they held a meeting, now known as the First Council of Nicea. At the meeting, everyone agreed to celebrate the Resurrection of Christ together. They agreed that the celebration would be on a Sunday. And they agreed to figure out the date on their own and to stop asking their Jewish neighbors. They didn’t work out all the details, though, so there were still occasional differences. In Britian, for example, in the seventh century, there were arguments over which set of tables to use to determine the date of the full moon, and whether it was okay to celebrate the Resurrection on the 14th of Nisan when the 14th of Nisan fell on a Sunday. When King Oswiu and his wife couldn’t agree to celebrate the Resurrection on the same day, the Synod of Whitby was called to resolve the differences.
Eventually, the differences were resolved everywhere. Eventually, all Christians calculated the date of Pascha according to the method developed in Alexandria and endorsed by Rome: the Resurrection would be celebrated on the Sunday that fell on or after the first full moon after the Spring equinox. And to make it easy, everyone agreed to use March 21 as the date of the equinox, and they agreed to count the full moon as being the 14th day of the lunar month.
Leap years and the Gregorian and Julian calendars
That system worked for a very long time. But the calendar everyone used at the time (now called the Julian calendar) didn’t accurately account for leap years. As a result, every 133 years, March 21 would move a day farther away from the equinox.
In 1582, the Roman Catholic Church adopted a new calendar (now called the Gregorian calendar) to push the equinox back closer to March 21 and keep it there. Over the next 300 years, the Gregorian calendar was adopted for civil and religious uses by nearly everyone — everyone except Orthodox Christians. Some Orthodox Christians use the Gregorian calendar for fixed feasts, like Christmas, that fall on the same date every year. But all Orthodox Christians (except those in Finland) continue to use the Julian calendar to determine the date of Pascha.
Calculating the date of Pascha today
So if you want to know why Pascha is when it is, that’s it. If you are an Orthodox Christian, you use the Julian calendar to work out the date of Pascha. If you’re a Christian in a Western tradition, you use the Gregorian calendar to work out the date of Easter. Sometimes the two calendars give the same date, so that all Christians celebrate the Resurrection together, just like everyone agreed to do back in 325. But more often, Pascha comes a week or more after the Western celebration of Easter.
When is Pascha?: When is Pascha? When is Easter? This Paschal calendar provides the date of Pascha, the date of Easter, and related dates in 2017, 2018, 2019, and more.
How Easter got its name: Ancient goddesses don’t have anything to do with it.
The website of the U.S. Naval Observatory provides more information about the astronomy involved in calculating the date of Easter and Pascha. The parish church of St. Wilfrid, Bognor, provides more information about the Synod of Whitby.